Programs & Campaigns
A Message to People Who Care about Rats
When
is an animal not an animal. . . rats as research 'tools' in laboratory
experiments
Millions
of rats are being used in painful and useless experiments
Did you know that...
Since its inception in 1966, rats have not been considered "animals"
under the Animal Welfare Act (AWA), the only U.S. federal law that
provides even minimal protection for animals in laboratories?
Consequently, millions of rats are used
annually in experiments, without ANY guarantee of anesthesia, analgesics,
adequate husbandry* or even a "humane" death.
* "Husbandry" includes
feeding, cleaning, enclosure size, and housekeeping. In approved
protocols, even these minimal "protections" can be withheld
if deemed "necessary" to the study.
Though treated like "things,"
rats suffer greatly from the stress and hardship of life and death
in the laboratory.
In U.S. laboratories, millions of animals
suffer and die. Approximately 90-95% of these animals are rats,
mice and birds perhaps the most exploited of all research
"tools." Yet rats, mice and birds are not covered by the
AWA.
Here are just a few examples of
what is going on ...
Behind the Laboratory Door
"The lab had a room where technicians
practiced on rats. Often I would open the lid of the boxes and see
mother rats nursing and trying to protect their babies. Techs would
reach into the boxes and grab one of the rats to practice, for example,
intubation. Because speed was of the essence a tech was required
to intubate a certain number of rats per minute rats were
often injured. I saw many bleeding from their mouths and
squirming in pain. They were just thrown back into the box to be
used again and again until they died." laboratory technician
"
[the researchers] made an incision
in his neck and
inserted a catheter in his heart. The tube
was passed behind his ear to keep the rat from going after it. Now
the anesthesia was stopped and the rat was turned onto his stomach.
A plastic dome
was put over him. The tube to his heart passed
out a hole in the dome, and the rat was left for the anesthetic
to wear off
but his back feet and legs were taped down, because
hed try to get away. Then it was time for the heart attack
.
First a paralyzing drug is shot into the catheter
and then
a drug to cause a heart attack. The injections were done quickly
but death was not quick, nor was he paralyzed completely
.
He jerked many times and his head turned from side to side
.
Tears started to run down my face. I wanted to take the
little guy and gently bury him. I keep seeing that poor helpless
little creature trying to escape, twitching in pain, and lying there
discarded like a used tissue."
member of an Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee
(IACUC)
In addition, researchers themselves inadvertantly tell
us how callously they handle rats:
"
[the researcher] would try
to inject the rats, miss them, drop them, spend half the morning
chasing the rats around the room or vice versa, flailing with a
broom to get them out from behind the sink, and so on. At the end
of a number of months of this, [he] examined the rats and discovered
the rats had peptic ulcers, greatly enlarged adrenal
glands
and shrunken immune tissues
the tip of the
iceberg of stress-related disease."
Robert Sapolsky, PhD, Why Zebras Dont
Get Ulcers
Feeling Beings, Not Research "Tools"
Contrary to what researchers want you to
believe, rats are sensitive and experience pain, fear and stress.
They show emotions that scientists are only beginning to acknowledge,
including pleasure, playfulness and joy. According to Discover
magazine (May 2002), "
[laboratory] rats responded
with playful nips and ultrasonic chirps when psychologists tickled
their ribs and bellies."
People who know rats as companion animals
know that they are inquisitive, intelligent, affectionate and social.
Rats in laboratories are no different, although science conveniently
strips them of these qualities to try to justify their cruel and
careless use and abuse. Rats destined for laboratories are bred
for their sweet and docile nature, making them even more vulnerable.
"Consider the most commonly used species in toxicology
research, the rat. Rats have no gall bladder. They excrete bile
very effectively
. Drugs bind to rat plasma much less efficiently.
Rats always breathe through the nose ... so rats get a different
mix of substances entering their systems
. Their gut flora
are in a different location. Their skin has different absorptive
properties than that of humans. Any one of these discrepancies will
alter drug metabolism. And these are only differences [from humans]
on a gross level."
Ray Greek, MD, and Jean Swingle Greek, DVM, Sacred
Cows and Golden Geese
Big Business in Rat Research
Rats have historically been completely deprived
of any protections. Through decades of AWA revisions granting minimal
protection to other species, rats were exempted. Why? Because billions
of rats used in research and testing generate billions of dollars
for breeders and provide a never-ending supply of "cheap,"
"disposable," living organisms. The price of rats for
experiments and testing ranges between five and hundreds of dollars
for specially bred and "engineered" rats. Multiply this
by millions of animals a year and the industrys profit-driven
motive is clear.
The breeding and sale of rodents is an expanding
industry that includes, along with caging and equipment, the production
of dozens of varieties of rats, including ones who are genetically
altered. There is even a "rat boutique where researchers can
browse for rare breeds and special genetically engineered models."
According to a spokesperson, the Rat Resource and Research Center
offers a variety of inbred, hybrid and genetically modified rats
including one strain whose "brain has been chemically damaged"
and another engineered to become obese.
"Convulsions, tears, diarrhea and bleeding from the
eyes or mouth and unusual vocalizations are typical
symptoms in the dying animals."
Robert Sharpe, MD, Cruel Deception, on
the Lethal Dose 50 (LD50) toxicity test
Unsound and Invalid
The motivation behind rat research is profit,
not shuman health and well-being. There are many reasons why the
rat is an unsound model for toxicity testing and other experiments.
Rat anatomy and physiology differ enormously from that of humans,
and the dissimilarities render research invalid and harmful when
extrapolated to humans. For example, rats rarely vomit; do not have
a gall bladder; do not have sweat glands; cannot pant; are poor
regulators of body temperature; have twice the concentrating ability
for urine; and, have a heart rate four times that of a human.
Many drug studies on rats were inaccurate
and dangerous when extrapolated to humans, including Flosint, an
arthritis medication, which proved fatal to humans; Zelmid, an antidepressant,
which caused neurological damage in humans; and Clioquinal, an antidiarrheal,
which caused blindness and paralysis in humans all
despite animal testing.
Bad Science=Bad Ethics
Congress just voted to continue to exclude
rats, mice and birds from AWA coverage. NEAVS, an anti-vivisection
organization committed to exposing and ending ALL vivisection on
ALL species, continues to work with other organizations to secure
protection for these excluded animals.
A study described in Science
magazine indicates that the majority of scientists who
routinely review animal research protocols as part of
Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees (IACUCs) also believe
these animals should be covered. The opinion of these individuals
who are on the front lines of seeing what is done every day to these
animals adds enormous weight to the argument
that all animals ought to be included.
Yet, heavily funded lobbying efforts by
those who profit from the unregulated, anything-goes use of rats
in research continue to try to deny these animals any coverage at
all.
© 2002. Provided as a public service.
|