Programs & Campaigns
Activists Protest Massachusetts Teachers Association
(Boston, MA) Sept. 8, 2003 - Beginning September 8, activists will
maintain a daily lunch hour presence outside the Massachusetts Teachers
Association's (MTA) headquarters at 20 Ashburton Place in Boston.
Organized by the Ethical Science and Education Coalition (ESEC),
this protest will draw attention to the MTA's opposition to Massachusetts
House Bill 1252, An Act Relative to Dissection Choice.
Introduced by Representative Louis Kafka (D-Sharon), H.1252 will
protect students from academic penalty if their religious or ethical
beliefs require alternatives to animal dissection.
From September 8 until the day of the bill's hearing at the State
House, activists will inform the public about MTA's continuing opposition
to granting students the legally protected right to choose humane
alternatives to traditional specimen dissection.
The MTA's interference in lobbying against H.1252 has kept passage
of this bill at bay for years, despite compelling evidence that
many MA teachers support such legislation. Says ESEC president Dr.
Theo Capaldo, "A recent Tufts University (2001) study shows
that a nearly two-thirds or 64% of Massachusetts life science teachers
support a dissection choice bill."
In addition, Capaldo points out, "The Tufts study indicates
that 20-25% of MA teachers admit that they refuse students of conscience
alternatives. At previous legislative hearings, former and current
students, often in tears, have testified in front of the Massachusetts
legislature and the MTA about forced dissections, thwarted science
careers, and academic failure. It's incomprehensible that the MTA
continues to be against this reasonable bill."
Comparative studies show that students using alternatives learn
as well as, if not better than students doing traditional animal
dissection. All alternatives are reusable, many are available free
from the Internet and loan libraries, and none require costly hazardous
waste disposal, making alternatives not only educationally sounds,
but also environmentally and fiscally responsible -- as well as
humane.
Adds Capaldo, "ESEC's presence at the MTA headquarters will
inform the general public that the MTA's opposition to the protection
of a student's right to choose humane alternatives is outdated,
unsubstantiated and not reflective of popular - or even their own
members'- opinion. The daily presence is a wake-up call to those
few lobbyists for MTA who are sorely out-of-touch with 2003 science
education and the absolute necessity to respect compassionate students."
For copies of H.1252 or more information or to arrange for an interview/article,
contact the ESEC office at (617) 523-6020 or visit the ESEC website
at www.neavs.org/esec
|